Reading Room Slipover Test Knitter Roundup

The Reading Room Slipover is a classic textured vest with a large range of options to make it your own. Choose between V-neck or a crew neck, between a high hip length or a cropped length, and add an optional high-low hem if you want it.

The substantial fabric of the diagonal stitch texture makes for a satisfying and warm garment perfect for layering. The density and slipped stitches in it also lends structure and creates a stable fabric that truly gives you that classic library-reading-room, tailored style.

Make it yours by choosing the shaping versions that fit your personal style and existing wardrobe. This vest is truly a classic-meets-modern take on the slipover that you can knit over and over again.

Pattern info page and purchasing links can be found here.

Disclaimers: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which means we may receive a small commission, at no additional cost to you, if you decide to make a purchase through one of our recommended partners. Some of these testers received partial or full yarn support from Aimee Sher Makes. None of the testers were required to share photos, and those featured here have consented to have these images shared. Some made unique mods to the pattern for their bodies, some of which are included in the pattern and some are not. Thank you to our test knitters for your help!

Size A to fit an upper bust measurement of 31" / 78.5 cm

Alice C. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Purl Soho Good Wool in Teal Abyss. She has this to say about her finished slipover: "This was a fun pattern to work up! The textured stitch was easy to memorize and adds interest to a basic piece. It pairs well with so many things in a typical wardrobe, and it's perfect for transitional and cold weather. Definitely worth the knit!"

Deborah G. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a plain hem using De Rerum Natura Candide in Azur.

Sylvan T. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Purl Soho Good Wool in Wild Guava.

Size B to fit an upper bust measurement of 34" / 86.5 cm

Yeji A. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Harrisville Designs Shetland in Evergreen. She has this to say about her slipover: "I really enjoyed making this size and body-inclusive vest! The texture is engaging, and the v-neck is super flattering!"

Céline G. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a high-low hem using Retrosaria Rosa Pomar Vovo in 02 Grey.

Ness S. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the cropped length with a split hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse in Pavot. They added a 2" / 5 cm bust dart and has this to say about their slipover: "Aimee Sher patterns always combine incredible fit with impeccable style, and the Reading Room Slipover is no exception. The pattern has so many options for getting the perfect fit and gives multiple options for necklines, length, and hem. The stitch pattern takes a classic slipover and elevates it."

Patti C. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a split hem using The Wandering Flock Cotton Lino in Celadon. She lengthened the body by 1" / cm and has this to say about her slipover: "The textured pattern is easy to memorize and becomes a meditative make. As someone who normally makes top-down garments, the slipover pattern was easy to follow and has convinced me that bottom-up patterns aren't scary and create beautiful garments."

Peyton S. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a split hem using Wooldreamers Saona in Guthrie. She has this to say about her slipover: "I love this new addition to my wardrobe! It’s already becoming a staple during the cooler seasons. It was such a fun pattern to knit with the diagonal stitch pattern. I’m tempted to make another one in green to add another to my wardrobe. I love Aimee’s attention to detail and description of techniques in the pattern, it prevents knitters from having to do something like search “how to do a tubular bind off” for the millionth time."

Size C to fit an upper bust measurement of 37.5" / 95.5 cm

Amanda M. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a plain hem using De Rerum Natura Candide in Azur. She shortened the body by 2" / 5 cm and says this about her slipover: "The Reading Room Vest is classic with a twist … the texture is easy to master but adds to the usual tailored fit and customisation options that ASM always delivers!"

Amy K. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Sadnes Garn Sunday and Alapakka Folgetrad held double. She has this to say about her slipover: "This is one of my favorite patterns of all time! I got so many compliments on it the first time I wore it out. The texture is unique and easy to knit, and I love that there are a multitude of options for customization: bust darts, neckline, hem… this is a truly versatile pattern that you can make your own."

Theresa G. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a high-low hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse in Poivre et Sel. She added a 1" / 2.5 cm bust dart and lengthened the armhole depth by 1" as well. She has this to say about her slipover: "This was such an enjoyable knit from beginning to end! And it is an incredibly useful addition in my wardrobe. Highly recommend this beautiful and practical pattern!"

Jaime M. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Big Little Yarn Co. Organic Wool Linen Fingering in Matcha.

Size D to fit an upper bust measurement of 40.75" / 103.5 cm

Mireille G. followed the V-neck view knit to high-hip length with a plain hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse in Cèdre. She shortened the body by 1'' / 2.5 cm.

Christina B. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a high-low hem using The Fibre Co. Cumbria Fingering in Scafell Pike. She shortened the body by 3 cm.

Isa P. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the cropped length with a split hem using Wooldreamers Saona in Guthrie. They added a 1" / 2.5 cm bust dart.

Meghan R. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a plain hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse in Caramel. She shortened the body by 2" / 5 cm and modified the neckline for a slight scoop rather than crew-neck. She has this to say about her slipover: "This is a versatile pattern that was easy to follow and gives a beautiful result!"

Alexandra O. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a high-low hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse. She added a 1" / 2.5 cm bust dart and lengthened the neckline and armhole depths.

Size E to fit an upper bust measurement of 44" / 112 cm

Rebecca C. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a split hem using Purl Soho Good Wool in Wild Mustard. They added a 1" / 2.5 cm bust dart.

Victoria H. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a plain hem using Nordic Yarn Eco Cashmere in Light Blue. They added a 4" / 10 cm bust dart and lengthened the body by 2" / 5 cm. They also graded between sizes by casting on Size F and decreasing at the waist to Size E and have this to say about the slipover: "Another ultra easy-to-wear pattern from Aimee Sher Makes! I appreciate how the pattern has built-in optional instructions for bust darts, I now always add them to garments. I have been wearing my vest nonstop since its finished."

Size F to fit an upper bust measurement of 47.25" / 120 cm

Jennifer J. followed the V-neck view knit to the high-hip length with a split hem using Bijou Basin Range Bijou Spun in favorite Old Boots. She added a 1" / 2.5 cm bust dart and shortened the body by 2" / 5 cm and has this to say about the slipover: "This pattern is such an addictive knit. Easy enough to see and remember the stitch pattern but never boring. Fit is excellent as always with Aimee Sher patterns. And I loved the options too. Since it’s sport weight and sleeveless, I’ll get lots of wear out of it. And it goes with almost everything in my closet."

Jordan M. followed the V-neck view knit to the cropped length with a split hem using Wooldreamers Saona in Guthrie. They added a 3" / 7.5 cm bust dart and added 2" / 5 cm in length to the body and have this to say about the slipover: "I love my finished slipover, and the entire knitting process was so enjoyable. Already thinking of one in a bouncy wool. The stitch pattern is a great opportunity to practice working elements “in pattern” (decreases, darts, etc.) because the pattern makes it easy to understand and follow."

Nicole K. followed the Crew-neck view knit to the cropped length with a split hem using De Rerum Natura Ulysse in Rose Quartz. She added a 2" / 5 cm bust dart and has this to say about the slipover: "I am a vest lover after knitting this piece! I receive so many compliments every time I wear it and its so light weight in the Ulysse yarn."

Once again, a huge thanks to our test knitters!